Something Widely Believed in Leadership That I Think Is Wrong

leadership

The Belief

A lot of leaders think their job is to have the answer. Someone raises a problem in a meeting, and the room waits for the person at the head of the table to solve it. Say “I’m not sure” too often and people start to wonder why you’re in the chair.

I think this belief does real damage. I have run businesses across very different markets, with people from very different backgrounds, and the leaders who insisted on always having the answer were rarely the ones their teams trusted most.

Why It Persists

It persists because it feels efficient. A confident answer moves a meeting along. A room full of open questions feels slow, even unproductive, especially to a board or an investor watching the clock.

It also persists because admitting you don’t know something can feel like weakness, particularly if you’ve spent decades building a reputation for judgment. Nobody wants to be the CEO who shrugs.

But efficiency in the room is not the same as being right. I have watched confident, fast answers send a business in the wrong direction more than once. The cost just shows up later, when it’s harder to trace back to the meeting where it started.

What I Think Is Actually True

The best leaders I’ve worked with treat not knowing as information, not a gap to hide. If you don’t have the answer, that tells you something: maybe the question needs more people in the room, maybe it needs more time, maybe it’s the wrong question entirely.

I do not believe any one person, however senior, holds a monopoly on the right idea. I’ve said this to staff and to clients for years: I don’t have sole license on brains. Neither does anyone else in the room. The moment a leader forgets that, the team stops offering their best thinking, because why bother if the boss already knows?

What This Looks Like Day To Day

In practice, this means I ask more questions than I answer, especially early in a problem. Not performative questions designed to look thoughtful, but real ones: what matters here, who else needs to weigh in, what are we assuming that might not be true.

It also means slowing down before a decision gets made, not after. Most leaders I’ve seen get into trouble didn’t lack intelligence. They moved too fast on too little information because slowing down felt like it would cost them credibility.

Where This Gets Tested

This gets hardest under pressure, when a board wants a decision this week and the instinct is to project total certainty. That’s exactly when I try to resist it most.

I’ve found that a leader who says “here’s what I know, here’s what I don’t, and here’s how we’ll find out” earns more trust over time than one who guesses confidently and gets it wrong. People remember who was honest with them when it counted.

This is not the same as indecision. Once the information is in, I make the call and I hold it. But I try to separate the gathering from the deciding, instead of collapsing both into a single confident-sounding moment.

What I’d Tell Someone Building A Team

If you’re building or leading a team across markets or functions that don’t naturally agree with each other, this matters even more. People from different backgrounds will read “the leader has all the answers” differently depending on where they were trained. Some will defer instantly. Others will quietly disengage because they assume their view isn’t wanted.

Either way, you lose the thing you actually need, which is the range of perspective in the room. I would rather build a team that argues with me and tells me when I’m missing something, than one that nods and waits to be told what to think.

The Trade-Off

There is a real cost to this approach. It is slower. It can look, from the outside, like you’re less in control than the leader down the hall who has an instant answer for everything. Some boards will read that as weakness before they read it as discipline.

I accept that trade-off. In my experience, the businesses that hold up over years are run by people who were honest about what they didn’t know, and built the habit of finding out before they acted. The ones that get built on confident guesses tend to need rebuilding sooner than anyone expected.

Share:

More Posts

City skyline representing new market expansion

Should You Build Your Way Into a New Market, or Buy Your Way In

The Choice Every Expansion Plan Comes To At some point in a growth conversation, someone asks the question that decides everything else: do we build our own operation in this market, or do we acquire one that already exists? It sounds like a financial question. It gets treated like one too, with spreadsheets comparing the cost of a greenfield team against the price of a

Business colleagues collaborating around a meeting table

Why Two Good Teams Still Struggle to Become One

A Deal That Looks Finished on Paper The contracts are signed. The org chart is drawn. Two teams that used to compete, or never worked together at all, now report into one structure. On paper, the merger is done. In the room, it isn’t close to done. I have sat in enough of these rooms to know the gap between the paperwork and the people.

Minimalist concrete pillars in a public plaza, illustrating restraint and dignity in institutional branding

When the Usual Branding Advice Is the Wrong Advice

The Advice That Works Almost Everywhere If you spend enough time in brand and marketing work, you learn a few rules that hold up almost everywhere. Say something distinct. Give people a reason to feel differently about you than they feel about the next option. Move first, move visibly, and keep moving. That advice is good advice. I have used it to help brands grow

Quiet path leading toward the beach, representing reflective walks and leadership clarity

The Habit That Earns Its Place in a Full Calendar

The Habit That Survives Every Busy Week Look at your calendar right now. I would guess it is full of meetings, calls, and things marked urgent. Somewhere in there is probably a block you keep moving: a walk, a gym session, time with no agenda. It gets pushed first because it looks the easiest to sacrifice. I protect one habit that never moves, no matter